What are the Silent Hill 2 remake gallows answers? When you reach Toluca prison in the original Silent Hill 2, you must make a choice between right and wrong, and whether the reasoning for certain crimes committed makes them justifiable. It's an interesting segment and one that perfectly suits the guilty undertones of James' story. Things are taken up a notch in the Silent Hill 2 remake gallows puzzle, as you must complete six poems before making your choice. Depending on your chosen riddle difficulty in the puzzle game, there are different answers for each puzzle, one innocent and one not so innocent. That said, it's not as much of a head-scratcher as it is perhaps a moral quandry. If you're unsure, here's our Silent Hill 2 gallows puzzle walkthrough. Continue reading Silent Hill 2 gallows puzzle solutions MORE FROM PCGAMESN: Silent Hill 2 remake system requirements, The best horror games, Silent Hill 2 remake review